Boy, this conversation is bringing back forum memories. On an earlier occasion I talked at length about exactly why the Waid FLASH is overrated and what it did wrong:
https://www.supermanthroughtheages.com/smf/index.php?topic=1991.0It was one of those "Me vs. Everybody" threads I thrive on, that are as envigorating to me as Irish Spring.
A few things I'd like to add:
1) As usual, Geoff Johns did right in many places what Waid did wrong. Impulse, for instance, once a hyperactive and annoying stereotype that reeked of insincerity, started to behave in a mature fashoin in Johns's TEEN TITANS. I can't believe I actually said that: I actually like Bart Allen now.
2) You might think, considering the low opinion I have of Waid's FLASH, that I'm depressed about him returning. Not really. Here's why: how anyone, even Mark "Barry has an evil twin" Waid be WORSE than the current Flash run?
Of course Flash would be better with Mark Waid, but then again it'd be better
canceled, too.