That's the secret to enjoying SMALLVILLE: don't think of it as Superman. Watch it as ROSWELL, but with only one main character.
I always think of it as Superman. To me, it was never anything else. I watched more than one season (up to the third, I think), and, like any show, it will deteriorate the longer it goes on; it starts to repeat itself. But basically I enjoyed the way the show dealt with some elements of Superman that had never been really closely examined before (not in the comics I'd read anyway).
Some things I liked:
Clark being torn in two because he desperately wants to open up to people but he is always forced into actually lying. And that's what young Clark Kent would have to cope with. He finds it painful, he is trying to figure it out, and we see him struggling with this.
The relationship between Clark and Lex, and a genuine sense of tragedy which is building... When things get tense between them, when Clark is forced to tell another lie, and Lex's seemingly good intentions go awry, and more suspicion creeps in, well... You can see that when things eventually go belly-up, it will be hard to pin the blame on one or the other, and that's the tragedy. All those good intentions were not enough. They are who they are, and it all has that feeling of fatalism.
The relationship between Clark and his Dad. Pa Kent in this show is great.
I LIKE SMALLVILLE's approach to teen life.
I do as well, in some ways. Occasionally they capture that sense of hopelessness, that your teenage relationships are turning bad despite good intentions on all sides, and no one can figure it out.
....I was stupid and inarticulate.
You mean you're not anymore?