Lighter? Perhaps. His opinion is based on ignorance and a habit of criticism without knowing the facts.
In a series of posts on his forum from early last August, he noted that "no 1940s story would be 26 pages long," he thinks the artwork is "insultingly bad," and he doesn't "buy" Roy Thomas' detective skills. Whenever anyone else posted something good about the story or tried to defend it, he would shoot them down. He also accused us of fraud.
We've all dedicated a lot of time, hard work, and love to this project and I am extremely pleased with what we've done so far. I was very insulted by his statements.
But I figure if Byrne doesn't like what we're doing; then it must be pretty good!