Which origin do you prefer?

[The Starchild]

OK, this is the companion poll -

If you were in charge at DC, which origin would you decree as being canonical?  Which one do you personally prefer?

[Klar Ken T5477]

Pre crisis, natch

[Kal's Pal]

Absoloutly Silver\Bronze Age, with the Loeb Redux being a close second. Both stories are simple, and give a richly textured origin to Superman.  

[The Starchild]

I actually voted for the Loeb silver-age redux, because it incorporates the MOS origin.  As much as I personally dislike Byrne's origin, I think it makes sense to have the Loeb origin because it can include all Superman stories - from Golden to Iron age - everything happened.  Thus, nothing gets thrown out, no fans or ages are disavowed or insulted.

[valdemar]

The traditionalist in me likes the classic Silver Age origin, but I voted for Birthright because it's just too much fun.  It pulls in some great stuff from the movie and from the Maggin-verse, both of which I've always loved.  And the costumes are fantastic.  

[TELLE]

I'm a fan of the genius-level refinement of the Weisinger era origin(s).

The story was always retold slightly differently to explore some never-before realized subtlety.

[Super Monkey]

Weisinger Silver Age Version is perfection in my opinion.

[Webley]

I had to pick Byrne's MOS
Its the one I grew up with.